The Short Answer
Which Claims Usually Raise Premiums?
Which Claims Typically Do NOT Raise Premiums?
How Much Will Your Premium Increase?
Can Your Carrier Cancel Your Policy After a Claim?
Should You File or Self-Insure?
Key Takeaways
Hail, wind, and fire claims rarely raise premiums; water damage and liability claims are more likely to.
Typical premium increase: 5–25% at renewal, lasting 3–5 years.
Carriers cannot cancel mid-term for storm claims in Florida; they can only non-renew at renewal.
The additional settlement from filing almost always exceeds the total premium increase.
When damage exceeds 2× your deductible, filing usually makes financial sense.
Drew — Licensed Public Adjuster
Reviewed: November 6, 2026Licensed in Florida and Texas, Drew has helped over 1,500 homeowners recover denied and underpaid insurance claims.